Comparison

Chemical vs. Physical Changes: How to Tell Them Apart

Chemical ReactionsBeginner4 min read
On this page
  1. The key question
  2. Physical changes
  3. Chemical changes
  4. Five signs that a chemical change has happened
  5. The tricky ones
  6. Chemical vs. physical properties
  7. Quick answers

Melt an ice cube and you still have water. Burn a piece of paper and you’ll never get the paper back. Those two everyday events capture the difference between a physical change and a chemical change — and learning to tell them apart is one of the first skills in chemistry.

The key question

Is a new substance formed?

  • Physical change: the substance changes form, shape or state, but its chemical identity stays the same. No new substance is made.
  • Chemical change: atoms are rearranged into new substances with different properties. Bonds are broken and new bonds are formed.

Physical changes

Examples:

  • Melting, freezing, boiling, condensing, sublimation (all changes of state)
  • Cutting, tearing, crushing, bending
  • Dissolving sugar or salt in water
  • Stretching a rubber band
  • Magnetizing a piece of iron
  • Mixing sand and iron filings (and separating them with a magnet)

Ice, liquid water and steam are all H₂O. Crushed sugar is still sugar.

Physical changes are often (not always) easy to reverse: freeze the water again, evaporate the solution to get the salt back.

Chemical changes

Examples:

  • Burning (wood, gas, a candle)
  • Rusting iron
  • Cooking an egg, toasting bread, caramelizing sugar
  • Fruit ripening and food rotting
  • Digesting food
  • Baking soda fizzing with vinegar
  • Silver tarnishing
  • Fireworks exploding

Chemical changes are usually hard to reverse. You can’t un-bake a cake.

Five signs that a chemical change has happened

None of these proves it on its own, but together they’re strong evidence:

  1. A gas is produced that wasn’t there before — bubbles, fizzing (and not just boiling).
  2. A colour change — iron turning red-brown, a copper roof turning green.
  3. A precipitate forms — a solid suddenly appearing when two clear solutions are mixed.
  4. Energy is released or absorbed — heat, light or sound; burning, glowing, an unexpected temperature change.
  5. A new smell — rotting food, burnt toast.

The tricky ones

Dissolving salt in water. Usually classed as physical: evaporate the water and you get the salt back unchanged. Chemists do point out that the ionic lattice breaks up and water molecules bond to the ions, so it’s a borderline case — but introductory courses call it physical.

Boiling water. Physical. The bubbles are water vapour, not a new gas — the H₂O molecules stay intact. Compare electrolysis, where bubbles of hydrogen and oxygen are new substances: chemical.

Colour change on heating. A metal glowing red-hot is physical (it cools back to the same metal). Copper turning black when heated in air is chemical: it forms copper(II) oxide.

Candle burning. Both at once! The wax melting is physical; the wax vapour burning in the flame is chemical.

Cooking an egg. Chemical. The proteins change structure irreversibly — the egg won’t turn clear again when it cools.

Frying an egg in butter and the butter melting. Melting: physical. Butter browning: chemical.

Chemical vs. physical properties

The same distinction applies to properties:

  • Physical properties can be observed without changing the substance: colour, density, melting point, boiling point, hardness, conductivity, solubility. Our element pages list dozens of these for every element.
  • Chemical properties describe how a substance reacts, and you can only observe them by changing it: flammability, reactivity with water or acid, tendency to rust, toxicity, acidity.

Sodium’s silvery colour and low density are physical properties. The fact that it reacts violently with water is a chemical property.

Quick answers

Is dissolving a chemical change? Generally treated as physical, because the dissolved substance can be recovered unchanged.

Is rusting a chemical change? Yes — iron and oxygen form a new substance, hydrated iron(III) oxide.

Is cutting hair a chemical change? No, physical. Dyeing or perming hair, however, involves chemical changes.

Do physical changes involve energy? Yes — melting and boiling absorb energy, freezing and condensing release it — but no new substance forms. See exothermic vs. endothermic.

Advertisement

More from this topic: Chemical Reactions